Building Your Own Subreddit · · By Stewart Kaplan

How to Get Your First Community Members: Find the Gap

Start here: How to Create a Subreddit for Your Business: Find the Gap

TL;DR

  • Early community growth depends on direct outreach, not broad marketing, the first members typically come from an existing audience, personal invitations, or adjacent communities, not ads or cold traffic.
  • A new online community needs a clear purpose and visible activity before recruiting begins, since people will not join (or stay in) a space that looks empty.
  • Activation matters more than headcount, a smaller group of members who post, comment, and return is more valuable than a large list of people who never engage.
  • Founding-member incentives and borrowed audiences (podcasts, guest posts, partner communities) help attract the right early members without requiring a large existing following.
  • The practical next step is to prepare the space first, then reach out individually, since one-to-one invitations consistently convert better than broadcast announcements.

A community organizer welcomes a newcomer as a small group gathers around a table.

Most new communities fail not because the idea is weak, but because the first members show up to an empty room. Getting the first wave of participants requires a different approach than scaling an established community, and the tactics that work early on often look manual, slow, and deliberately small.

This matters because the first members shape whether a community survives past its first few weeks. Their activity, tone, and willingness to return set the pattern that later members will follow, for better or worse.

The sections below break down where early members actually come from, what needs to be in place before outreach starts, and how to tell the difference between a community that is growing and one that is just adding names to a list.

Identify the Gap and Recruit a Founding Group

Every strong community starts by solving a problem that no one else has solved yet. The process below covers how to spot that gap, shape an identity around it, and bring in the first members who will set the tone for everyone who joins later.

Find What Existing Communities Leave Unanswered

The gap shows up as a pattern, not a single complaint. Look for these signals before writing a single word of copy:

Signal Where to Find It What It Means
Same question asked repeatedly Reddit threads, Facebook Groups Current resources don't answer it well
Long threads with no good answer Comment counts high, top reply vague Expertise gap, not just an activity gap
Outdated pinned resources Group descriptions, wiki pages Members have nowhere current to turn
Members who already answer others well Reddit profiles, LinkedIn comments Potential founding members or moderators

Joseph Quan found this pattern directly. He ran short interviews with people in his target group and found that current HR networks had people repeating basic questions because good answers kept getting buried, which frustrated members searching for real insight.

Define the Ideal Member and Name the Community Around Their Needs

The ideal member is a specific person, not a broad category. Write down their job title, their daily frustration, and the one outcome they want from joining.

Then build the name and description around that outcome, not around the topic in general. A name that says exactly who it's for helps the right person recognize it in a search result or a group listing.

Quan's team decided early that the community would serve one single HR leader per company, and they held that line even when it meant turning people away. This kept conversations strategic instead of entry-level.

A clear ideal member also tells the founder what to leave out. If the name and description try to serve everyone, the first members won't feel like it was built for them.

Validate the Idea With Passionate Customers Before Building a Platform

Validation should happen before any app, forum, or paid tool gets built. A simple way to test it:

  1. Write a short description of the community idea.
  2. Send it to a small list of people who match the ideal member profile.
  3. Count how many reply with interest or questions.
  4. Interview a dozen of them about what existing groups get wrong.
  5. Use their answers to decide if the idea has enough pull to continue.

Quan tested three different pivot ideas through outbound email before building anything. The community idea got far more replies than the others, which gave him evidence to move forward with that direction.

This step also helps avoid the common mistake of guessing. A founder should not assume demand exists just because a topic feels popular.

Recruit Founding Members Through Personal Invites and an Existing Audience

Founding members rarely come from ads. They come from direct outreach and from people the founder already has some connection to.

  • Personal invites: Message people one by one, explain why they were picked, and ask directly.
  • Existing audience: Pull from an email list, past customers, or a personal network built before the community existed.
  • Referrals: Ask early members to bring one or two peers who fit the same profile.
  • Waitlists: Collect interested people before launch, then invite them in small batches.

A founder's first 5 to 10 members set the tone for the whole group, since early habits are far easier to keep than to fix later, according to JuntoGroups. Recruiting a tight group of 10 to 20 trusted people before opening things wider also helps establish culture while the group is still small enough to manage directly, a pattern described by Nomadexcel's community-building guide.

Use LinkedIn, Reddit, and Adjacent Groups to Build Trust, Not Advertise

LinkedIn, Reddit, and niche Facebook Groups work best as places to build trust, not places to post ads. The goal is to show up as a helpful participant first.

Platform How to Use It What to Avoid
LinkedIn Comment on posts from the ideal member's peer group Posting a generic invite link
Reddit Join subreddits where the ideal member already asks questions Dropping a community link with no context
Adjacent Slack community or Facebook Groups Answer questions members already have Copying the same message into multiple groups

A founder earns the right to mention their own community by first being useful in someone else's space. This is the difference between renting attention in someone else's corner and slowly earning standing that makes an invite welcome instead of ignored.

Product Hunt can work the same way for a product-adjacent community, since early users there are often willing to try something new if the founder engages directly in the comments rather than just posting a launch link.

Offer a Clear First Experience for Early Adopters

Early adopters need one moment that proves the community is worth their time. That moment should not depend on the group being large yet.

Weak version: A near-empty forum with a generic welcome message and no content.

Strong version: A short onboarding call, a small set of genuinely useful resources, and a clear next action for the new member to take.

Quan personally onboarded his first 50 members with a 30-minute walkthrough call for each one, using the time to ask what they valued most and what would bring them back daily. That direct contact shaped which features got built next.

A clear first experience doesn't need advanced features. It needs enough real value that the first members return on their own and start inviting others.

Make Early Participation Worth Returning For

A small group welcomes a newcomer and shares ideas around a table.

Early members decide whether to stick around based on what happens in their first few days, not their first few months. The sections below cover how to seed useful discussion, welcome new members well, keep people coming back, and hand off leadership as the group grows.

Seed Researched Content That Starts Substantive Discussions

A new community has no history to draw on, so the founder has to supply the first batch of substance.

What this looks like in practice:

Content type Why it works early Example topic
Comparison post Gives members a shared reference point Two tools or methods side by side
Data-backed breakdown Shows the founder did real work Survey results, benchmark numbers
Walkthrough Gives members something to replicate or critique Step-by-step process with screenshots
Open question with context Invites expertise instead of small talk A specific problem plus what's already been tried

Posts built on real research draw better replies than generic prompts like "what do you think?" Members respond to specifics, not open-ended filler.

This is the research step of the Right-Crowd Content System: content strong enough that passionate customers want to correct it, add to it, or argue with it.

Welcome Each Member and Make Their First Contribution Easy

Every new member should get a personal response to their first post, not silence.

Step-by-step flow:

  1. Notice a new member's first comment or post.
  2. Reply within a day, referencing something specific they said.
  3. Ask one direct follow-up question tied to their situation.
  4. Point them to one related thread or resource.
  5. The member now has a reason to come back and check for a reply.

Observation → decision → action:

Observation Decision Action
New member posts an intro with no replies after 24 hours Treat this as a drop-off risk Reply personally, don't let it sit
Member asks a question already answered elsewhere Treat this as a connection opportunity, not a duplicate to delete Link the old thread and summarize it for them
Member's first post is vague Treat this as a coaching moment Ask a clarifying question instead of ignoring it

A low-effort first contribution, like a one-line comment, still counts. The goal is a reply, not a perfect post.

Use Events, Group Coaching, and Email to Sustain Participation

Discussion threads alone will not keep most early members engaged between visits.

Formats that work at small scale:

  • Live group coaching calls where members bring real problems and get direct answers.
  • Recurring office hours with no fixed agenda, just open access to the founder.
  • Themed discussion weeks tied to a specific question or challenge.
  • Email marketing that recaps the best discussion from the week and asks a follow-up question.
  • Small-group video calls instead of large webinars, since early groups are still small enough for real conversation.

Email marketing matters here because not every member checks the community daily. A short recap email brings lapsed members back without requiring them to scroll through everything they missed.

Give Members Roles in Welcoming and Leading the Group

As members prove themselves, the founder should hand off specific tasks rather than keep doing everything personally.

Contrast block:

Founder keeps doing it Founder hands it off
Replies to every new member intro Asks an active member to welcome newcomers in their area of expertise
Writes every discussion prompt Invites a member to run a themed thread or short AMA
Answers every repeated question Points new members to a member-written resource
Moderates every rule-bending post alone Adds a trusted member as a moderator or discussion leader

This is the Shift to Member-Led Growth: members start contributing ideas and structure on their own, while moderation standards stay in place. Handing off tasks too early, before trust is earned, usually backfires, so founders should watch for members who already answer others well before offering a role.

Measure Engagement Before Expanding Acquisition

Growth efforts spent on new members mean little if existing members are quietly leaving.

What to track:

Signal What it tells the founder What to do if it's weak
Reply rate on new member intros Whether onboarding is working Fix the welcome process before adding more members
Return rate after first week Whether early value is real Revisit the first-week content and outreach
Number of members posting without prompting Whether the community growth flywheel is starting Seed more research-backed discussion topics
Repeat questions with no clear answer Whether existing resources are missing something Write a resource post addressing the gap

Community management at this stage means watching these signals weekly, not guessing. Expanding acquisition before fixing a weak return rate just produces more churn at a larger scale.

Learn From Knoetic, Mode, and Figma Without Copying Their Tactics

Each of these companies built community around a specific professional need, not a general interest.

  • Knoetic, founded by Joseph Quan, built CPOHQ as a community for chief people officers to discuss problems specific to that role, showing how a narrow professional focus can sustain serious discussion.
  • Mode built community around data analysts sharing real queries and dashboards, tying participation directly to their product's use case.
  • Figma grew community around designers sharing files and critique, which worked because the platform itself made sharing and feedback easy.

The lesson is not to copy their specific events or formats. It's that each company matched its community's structure to what its specific audience already wanted to discuss and share, which is the same decision any founder has to make for their own corner.

Frequently asked questions

Where can you find potential members for a new online community?

Potential members are already active in places where they discuss the exact problem the community solves.

Location Type Example What to Look For
Adjacent subreddit or forum A hobby subreddit for the same niche Questions asked repeatedly with no clear answer
Existing personal network Email list, newsletter, social followers People who've already expressed interest in the topic
Comment sections on niche content Blog posts, YouTube videos, podcasts Commenters debating details or asking follow-ups
Adjacent paid or free communities A Discord or Slack group one step removed from the topic Members who outgrew the group's scope

The builder should check whether a given space tolerates outside links or invites before posting there. Some communities ban self-promotion outright, and a single rule-breaking post can burn the relationship before it starts. This is the research step that supports finding your first 100 community members, the goal isn't broad exposure, it's finding where the right people already gather.

How do you convince people to join a community with no members yet?

An empty community has no social proof, so the pitch has to replace proof with specificity.

  • Name the exact person it's for. "A space for freelance illustrators negotiating contracts" beats "a community for creatives."
  • State what they get in one sentence. A vague promise reads as noise; a specific one reads as useful.
  • Show, don't just tell. Seed a few real discussions, a resource post, and a welcome thread before asking anyone to join, so new visitors see activity instead of an empty shell, a point echoed in guidance on getting a community's first 100 members.
  • Offer early access, not a finished product. Framing it as "help shape this" instead of "join this" gives early members a reason to tolerate a quiet space.

Weak pitch: "Join our new community for marketers!" Strong pitch: "A space for solo marketers to trade real campaign numbers, no gurus, no pitches, just what worked and what didn't."

Which outreach channels work best for attracting a community's first members?

Direct, personal outreach converts better than broadcast channels at this stage.

Channel Conversion Strength Best Use Case
1:1 personal invites (DMs) Highest Reaching people the builder already knows would be interested
Existing audience (email, social) High Builders with any pre-existing following
Guest appearances on podcasts or adjacent creators' channels Medium-high Borrowing an audience that already trusts the host
Helpful participation in adjacent communities Medium Starting from zero personal audience
Paid ads Low at this stage Not recommended before the community has any activity

This ranking matches what's documented in guides on where early community members actually come from: personal, unscalable tactics outperform scale tactics in the cold-start phase. Paid promotion works better later, once there's something active to show.

What should you offer early members to make joining worthwhile?

Early members take a risk on an unproven space, so the offer needs to reward that risk directly.

  1. Set a founding-member rate or tier. A discounted, grandfathered price for the first group gives them a lasting benefit for joining early.
  2. Give them a voice in shaping the space. Ask what topics, formats, or rules they want, and visibly act on the feedback.
  3. Grant early access to content or resources. A guide, template, or tool not yet available to the public works as a joining incentive.
  4. Recognize them publicly. A "founding member" badge or mention turns status into a reason to stay engaged.
  5. End with members who feel like co-builders, not just signups.

This approach lines up with advice on founding-member offers for new communities, which treats early joiners as invested participants rather than just a headcount.

How many founding members should you recruit before launching a community?

There's no fixed number, but the target should be measured in active participants, not total signups.

  • Observation: A community with 300 members but no replies in active threads looks dead to any new visitor.
  • Decision: Prioritize activation over raw member count before any public launch.
  • Action: Aim for a small group, often cited as the first 100, who are genuinely engaged, since 60 active members outperform 300 silent ones in making a space feel alive.

The builder should track how many new joiners take a first meaningful action, a comment, an introduction, a reply, rather than just how many click "join."

How do you keep your first community members engaged?

Early engagement depends on the builder's own visible presence, not on the group sustaining itself.

  • Reply within minutes, not days. Fast responses in the first weeks set the pace members expect going forward.
  • Welcome every new member by name. A personal greeting signals the space is actively run, not abandoned.
  • Seed discussions before members arrive. A handful of posts and comments already in place prevents a new joiner from seeing an empty thread.
  • Ask members to bring one person each. This works best after someone has already had a positive first experience, not before.
  • Watch for members who start answering others on their own. This signals the early stage of the Shift to Member-Led Growth, where the builder can step back slightly from constant posting while still moderating for quality.

The long-term goal is a community that runs partly on member contributions, with the builder maintaining standards rather than generating every post.